An Ohio Sheetz worker is accused of printing himself $17,000 in Keno tickets

See more of our coverage in your search results.
Police in Solon, Ohio, say a Sheetz employee printed himself $17,000 in Keno tickets over two months. “The thing that stood out when you look at transactions is some of them were pretty big, like somebody is really paying $500 for one Keno game. Who is doing that?” said Lt. Bill Vajdich, a spokesman for Solon police.
Joshua Hartley, 32, of Cleveland was arrested at the Sheetz at 5960 Cochran Road at about 1:49 p.m. on Thursday, November 5. Police charged him with theft, a fourth-degree felony. A loss prevention employee's audit “revealed $17,000 in losses through their state lottery keno system,” police said, and the Ohio Lottery Commission helped with it. Ohio law classifies theft of $7,500 or more but less than $150,000 as a fourth-degree felony. Hartley has only been charged, and these claims have not been tested in court.
Sheetz management built a log of the dates and times the suspicious tickets printed, and Hartley was on duty each time, police said. Investigators said store cameras captured him creating and printing a large number of Keno tickets for himself at the lottery kiosk, and police allege he knew how to get into the terminal without paying. “Sheetz doesn't even use that system for issuing individual lottery tickets and definitely not Keno tickets. But that software, that hardware, exists so that if somebody knew how to do it, they could do it,” Vajdich said.
Police say Hartley admitted accessing the machine numerous times over two months and told detectives the winnings helped pay his bills. Spread across September through early November, $17,000 comes to about $8,500 a month. He was carrying $1,944 in cash when he was arrested, about 11% of the alleged total. Officers seized it, expecting a court to order it returned to Sheetz through forfeiture. The police account does not say how much the tickets won.
Vajdich's $500 example takes some doing in Keno. Ohio's version takes wagers of $1 to $20 per drawing, one bet card can cover up to 50 straight drawings, and drawings run every few minutes from 6:04 a.m. to 2:29 a.m. Police did not say how those plays were set up.
| Case | State | What is alleged | Charge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solon Sheetz | Ohio | $17,000 in Keno tickets printed without paying | Felony theft |
| Baton Rouge Kangaroo Express | Louisiana | $5,485 in Fast Play tickets and winnings | Skimming of lottery proceeds |
| Duncan Circle K | South Carolina | Redeeming scratch-offs he never paid for | Lottery fraud |
| Summerville Circle K | South Carolina | Stealing scratch-offs and cashing them at the same store | Lottery fraud |
| Jonesboro store | Arkansas | Playing 64 tickets taken from the store that fired her | Two Class D felonies |
Those earlier cases are allegations too. Lottery terminals and store cameras leave records of what was printed, sold, or cashed, and stores track ticket packs as well. Asked whether the alleged scheme was clever or foolish, Vajdich said, “Maybe a little of both, but when it comes to the lottery, the house is always going to win.” The reports do not include a response from Hartley.
Sources
WJW Fox 8: Cleveland man arrested after creating his own Keno tickets
WJW Fox 8: How a Sheetz worker allegedly stole $17K through Keno
Found this article useful?
Add ScratchCheck as a preferred source on Google to see our articles first.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Joshua Hartley accused of doing at the Solon, Ohio, Sheetz?
Police say the 32-year-old Cleveland man printed Keno tickets for himself at the store's lottery kiosk without paying, from September to early November 2026. He was arrested November 5 and charged with felony theft. The audit put the total at $17,000.
How did police say the Sheetz Keno scheme was caught?
A Sheetz loss prevention supervisor noticed losses tied to Keno sales, and the company audited the system with help from the Ohio Lottery Commission. Management logged when suspicious tickets printed and found one employee always on duty. Surveillance video showed the printing, police said.
What felony level is a $17,000 theft in Ohio?
Under Ohio Revised Code 2913.02, theft of property or services valued at $7,500 or more but less than $150,000 is grand theft, a fourth-degree felony. Police said the Keno case involves $17,000. Hartley has only been charged and is presumed innocent.

Jessie Jurado is a news writer who covers new scratch-off launches, state lottery guides, taxes on winnings, news, and much more. She joined ScratchCheck in 2026 and writes the site's state-by-state coverage.
Related Articles

Michigan players can now cash $601 to $49,999 scratch-off prizes in the Lottery app instead of going to a claim center
Nov 18, 2026, 1:32 PM EST

Georgia launched four new scratchers, and its $2 game has more than 2,000 top prizes
Nov 17, 2026, 1:55 PM EST

California launched five new Scratchers, and the cheapest one has the best odds of profit
Nov 17, 2026, 11:10 AM EST