Why stolen scratch-offs are close to worthless, even the winning ones

See more of our coverage in your search results.
A stack of stolen scratch-offs looks like cash, but it rarely works out that way. Lotteries track tickets by game, pack, and ticket number, and there are locks that stand between a thief and the prize money.
The first lock is activation. A store has to activate a pack in the lottery's system before it sells any tickets from it, and Texas rules say prizes in a pack can't be validated until then, as we explained here. A pack taken before activation is just paper. The Colorado Lottery won't even credit a store for stolen packs that were never activated, “as there is no financial liability.”
The second lock covers packs already on sale. In Wisconsin, a store reports the game, pack, and ticket numbers of missing tickets to a 24-hour retailer hotline, and the numbers go into the lottery's central computer as non-redeemable. “This removes their ability to be cashed,” the Wisconsin Lottery says. A clerk who scans one of those tickets will get a non-redeemable message instead of a payout message.
A validation attempt happens at a specific store at a specific time, usually in view of a camera, and anything over a store's cash limit has to be claimed with the lottery directly at a lottery office. In Delaware, for example, that means bringing photo ID and a Social Security card. In South Carolina, the State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) brings lottery fraud charges in these cases regularly.
| Case | What was taken | What happened |
|---|---|---|
| Columbia Circle K | Two packs worth $600 | Warrant says one ticket was cashed for $10; lottery fraud charge |
| Conway store | 2,229 tickets | Prizes on them totaled $8,691; employee charged |
| Goose Creek and Moncks Corner | 35 tickets | Scanned on a lottery app; lottery fraud charge |
| Palm Beach Gardens Winn-Dixie | 456 tickets | Scanned with the Florida Lottery app; theft charge |
| Tacoma, Washington, 2017 | 400 tickets worth $7,000 | Store said the tickets could be canceled |
| Bothell, Washington, 2017 | $3,000 in tickets | Canceled the next day, after $750 was redeemed |
The South Carolina and Florida cases are allegations, and each defendant is presumed innocent. The Washington pair from 2017 shows the system's weak spot. A Bothell store owner said he called to cancel $3,000 in stolen tickets at 5:30 p.m. but they weren't canceled until the next day, and the thieves redeemed $750 in the meantime, KOMO News reported. In Tacoma a week later, the owner's son said the store could cancel the stolen tickets. That gap is why some suspects scan tickets with a lottery app first, to find the few winners before the cancellation goes through.
Even a clean getaway yields little, because most scratch-offs lose. At the median US overall odds of 1 in 3.87, about three of every four tickets win nothing, and about four in 10 wins are free tickets or prizes that just return the price. The Conway case works out to about $3.90 in prizes per ticket, and the Columbia warrant describes $600 in tickets that produced one $10 cash-in. A store's real cost from a theft falls on the store and its insurer, while the thief is left holding paper that the lottery can switch off.
How we did this. Activation rules are from Texas Administrative Code Title 16, Section 401.370, and the Colorado Lottery's stolen scratch ticket procedure. The non-redeemable process is from the Wisconsin Lottery's retailer page, and the Delaware claim requirements are from the Delaware Lottery's guide to winning. Case details come from our earlier reports and from KOMO News reporting of May 11, 2017. The median overall odds cover active US state lottery games in our database on November 11, 2026.
Sources
Wisconsin Lottery: Stolen tickets
Colorado Lottery: Retailer stolen scratch ticket procedure
Delaware Lottery: Guide to winning
KOMO News: Thieves were able to cash in stolen scratch tickets despite security
Found this article useful?
Add ScratchCheck as a preferred source on Google to see our articles first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you cash a stolen lottery scratch-off?
Usually not for long. A pack that was never activated can't be validated at all, and once a store reports activated tickets stolen, lotteries such as Wisconsin's mark them non-redeemable in the central system. Thieves sometimes cash a few first.
What happens if you try to cash a stolen scratch-off?
A flagged ticket won't validate, and the attempt can tie the ticket to a store, a time, and often surveillance video. In South Carolina, SLED has charged people with lottery fraud for cashing stolen tickets, including one cashed for $10.
How much are stolen scratch-offs actually worth?
Much less than face value. At the median US overall odds of 1 in 3.87, about three of four tickets win nothing, and many wins are free tickets or money back. In one South Carolina case, 2,229 tickets held $8,691 in prizes.

Phil Nageotte is a writer covering scratch-off odds, expected value, prize data, and more. He joined ScratchCheck in 2026 after years of tracking lottery payouts in spreadsheets of his own.
Related Articles

These are the states where you can pay $0 in taxes on lottery winnings
Nov 11, 2026, 1:18 PM EST

Lotto America explained: 11 times better jackpot odds than Powerball, sold in 16 states
Nov 3, 2026, 11:41 AM EST

How a UK Powerball jackpot is paid, and why it is £404 million when America's is $760 million
Oct 31, 2026, 11:33 AM EDT