Creepy CashNew Mexico Scratch-Off Odds & Prizes Remaining
Creepy Cash costs $2 a ticket from the New Mexico Lottery. Top prizes have been claimed faster than tickets sold, so the $500 prize now runs about 1 in 32,244 by our estimate, against 1 in 12,389 at launch. No $2 ticket in New Mexico has better overall odds: 1 in 3.81, against 10 others at that price. Its prize pool is nearly spent: 13% of prizes remain.
Should I Buy This Ticket?
- Top-prize odds have worsened: 1 in 12K at launch, about 1 in 32K now. The $500 prizes are being claimed faster than tickets sell.
- Most of this game's prizes are gone.
- At $0.60 returned per $1, this game pays back less than most scratch-offs.
Current Prize Odds
ScratchCheck estimate · Updated October 19Prize Breakdown
| Prize | Odds | Total | Left | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | 1 in 12,398 | 20 | 1 | 5% |
| $100 | 1 in 1,442 | 172 | 11 | 6% |
| $50 | 1 in 606 | 409 | 34 | 8% |
| $20 | 1 in 150 | 1,652 | 117 | 7% |
| $10 | 1 in 50 | 4,956 | 504 | 10% |
| $5 | 1 in 21 | 11,559 | 1,175 | 10% |
| $3 | 1 in 15 | 16,525 | 2,257 | 14% |
| $2 | 1 in 14 | 18,172 | 2,646 | 15% |
| $2 | 1 in 21 | 11,569 | 1,718 | 15% |
Prize Pool Analysis
Ticket Statistics
Prize History
Top prizes left
Since March 6, when our records for it began, 2 $500 top prizes have been reported claimed, leaving 1. The most recent was on May 4.
- May 4, 20261 claimed · 1 left
- March 12, 20261 claimed · 2 left
How fast it's selling
Over the last 4 weeks, about 0.1% of this game's prizes were reported claimed each week, well below the average for New Mexico's $2 games (1% a week).
From ScratchCheck's daily record of the lottery's published prize counts. Dates are when a claim first appeared in those counts, and small prizes are often cashed days after purchase, so claims trail actual sales.
ValueScore™ Breakdown
Game Details
- State
- New Mexico
- Game Number
- 656
- Ticket Price
- $2
- Start Date
- 9/2/2025
- Payout %
- 59.9%
- Data Source
- Official
- Last Updated
- 10/19/2026
Compare
Compare this game with another →Official Source
View on New Mexico Lottery ↗Simulate This Game
Run a virtual scratch-off using this game's real odds.
Entertainment only. Outcomes are random and won't match a real session. Current-odds mode scales each tier by remaining prizes and tickets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Every $2 ticket in New Mexico
All 11 ranked →| Game | ValueScore | Odds | Payout | Top prize · left | Claimed per week |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ELF | 62 | 1 in 3.98 | 58.9% | $500 · 19 | - |
| $5,000 Grande | 60 | 1 in 3.99 | 58.8% | $5K · 3 | 1.7% |
| Betty Boop™ | 50 | 1 in 4.05 | 60.2% | $5K · 2 | 1.7% |
| Fast Cash | 49 | 1 in 3.99 | 58.8% | $500 · 9 | 1.4% |
| Creepy Cash (this game) | 46 | 1 in 3.81 | 59.9% | $500 · 1 | 0.1% |
| I Love Cash | 38 | 1 in 3.99 | 57.9% | $5K · 2 | 1.3% |
| 777 | 37 | 1 in 3.99 | 58.8% | $7K · 2 | 1.6% |
| 7-11-21® Tripler | 34 | 1 in 4.04 | 58.9% | $2K · 2 | 0.8% |
| Merry Money 5X | 27 | 1 in 3.93 | 58.3% | $500 · 5 | 0.1% |
| Hit $50 | 25 | 1 in 4.17 | 58.7% | $50 · 193 | 0.0% |
Claimed per week: share of each game's printed prizes reported claimed per week over the last 4 weeks, from our daily records of the lottery's prize counts.